COOKBOOK CONFIDENTIAL COOKBOOK CLUB – Dorothy Grover Read reviews Oh She Glows for Dinner

Rate this post

Hi there,

I was intrigued by the review from my friend Dorothy Grover-Read, who runs Like my review, she did not recommend the cookbook. It was especially intriguing to me since she typically cooks a very plant-based diet. This is one of the many rewarding aspects of our club – we have members from diverse backgrounds with varying opinions.

 My friend Bernadette from New Classic Recipe ( came up with the wonderful idea to have an on-line cookbook club with some of her blog buddies. What a fun, and great way to choose a recipe or two from the books, cook them, and review them. Then, you decide if the book is worth you shelf space! Please go to her site for other reviews.

      The cookbook informs us on the cover that it is composed of nourishing plant-based meals to keep you glowing. It is divided into main dishes, sides and small bites, meal-worthy salads, hearty soups and stews, treats and drinks, and sauces, dressings, and spices. In her introduction, Liddon says “Oh She Glows for Dinner is going to provide you with tools, tips, and tricks to help you get more plant based meals on the table, and in the process, you’ll hopefully fall in love with so many vibrant, balanced, and downright irresistible recipes.”

Good tips

      The book has a lot of good tips on storage, leftovers, substitutions, and other variations which I found handy.

I chose two to cook: Festive Bread-Free Stuffing Balls and Ultimate Creamy Salt and Vinegar Scalloped Potatoes.


Ultimate Creamy Salt-and-Vinegar Scalloped Potatoes

·      1 batch Garlic Cashew Cheese Sauce (below)

·      1 batch Vegan Parmesan (below)

·      2 pounds (900 g) Yukon Gold or yellow potatoes, peeled

·      Fine sea salt

·      A few generous pinches of fresh or dried thyme leaves, for garnish (optional)

      Prepare the Garlic Cashew Cheese Sauce, followed by the Vegan Parmesan, and set both aside. 

      Preheat the oven to 425°F (220°C). Liberally oil a 9 by 13-inch casserole dish, making sure to coat the sides and bottom completely.

      Using a mandoline, slice the peeled potatoes into very thin (less than ⅛-inch-thick/2 mm) slices (no thicker, or they’ll take a long time to cook through).

      Spread a single layer of sliced potatoes over the bottom of the casserole dish, just barely overlapping, covering the bottom of the dish. Sprinkle a small pinch of salt over the sliced potatoes. Pour a scant 1 cup of the cashew cheese sauce over the potatoes so it covers the potatoes’ surface completely, using your fingers or the measuring cup to spread it out. The sauce will look thin and watery, but will thicken while baking.        

      Repeat this layering process until you have used all the sauce and sliced potatoes, five layers with sauce the last. It will look like too much sauce, but will firm up as it bakes.

      Sprinkle all the parmesan over the sauce. Cover the casserole dish with aluminum foil., and cut slits in it to let the steam escape.

      Bake for 1 hour, then remove the foil and check for doneness by sliding a knife into the center of the casserole. There should be no resistance; if there is, replace the foil and bake for 5 to 15 minutes more, then test again.

      Serve with a sprinkling of thyme leaves, if desired.

Cooks Notes:

Scalloped potatoes are definitely part of my childhood and one of my favorite potato comfort foods, and I’ve made my mom’s recipe vegan on more than one occasion by simply substituting plant milk for dairy. She never used cheese in hers.

       This recipe is very different than what we’re used to. It used very thinly sliced potatoes (2 mm) a cashew-based cream sauce, and a “Vegan Parmesan” topping. I was promised that I would fall into a heavenly trance. That’s a tall order, and sadly it did not deliver. 

Not quite a big hit

      It was good, with just a hint of the vinegar, and pretty creamy but not ultra, and after reheating was not very creamy at all. Most importantly, it didn’t taste anything at all like scalloped potatoes. A few onions might have gone a long way. My husband really liked it, but doused it with pepper (there was no pepper in the recipe, which I also thought it needed, potatoes being potatoes). 

Recipes within a recipe

      The dish involved making the cashew sauce, in a blender, which involved pre-soaking them over night. We also had to make the vegan Parmesan cheese, another step and a food processor. Not counting the soaking time of course, the recipe took an hour to make, not 25 minutes. Definitely not a weeknight dinner side dish.

Festive Bread Free Stuffing Balls

virgin olive oil

·       1 (8-ounce/225 g) package cremini mushrooms

·       3 large garlic cloves, minced

·       1 cups (25 g) stemmed kale leaves

·       1 cup (25 g) fresh parsley

·       1/2 cup plus 2 tbsp. (65 g) gluten-free rolled oats

·       1 (14-ounce/398 ml) can lentils, drained and rinsed, or 1 ½ c. 

·       1 cup (100 g) walnut halves

·       1 teaspoon dried thyme (or 2 teaspoons fresh)

·       1/2 teaspoon dried oregano

·       1/4 teaspoon dried rosemary (or 1/2 teaspoon fresh, minced)

·       1/3 cup (40 g) dried cranberries, finely chopped

·       1 tablespoon (15 ml) ground flax

·       2 1/2 teaspoons (12.5 ml) sherry vinegar

·       3/4 to 1 teaspoon fine sea salt, to taste

·       Freshly ground black pepper

      Preheat the oven to 350°F (180°C) and line a baking sheet with parchment paper.

      Add the oil to a large skillet and turn heat to medium. Finely chop the mushrooms until they’re roughly the size of peas. Add chopped mushrooms to the pot along with minced garlic and a pinch of salt. Stir until combined. Sauté for about 6 to 8 minutes, until the water from the mushrooms cooks off, reducing heat to low if necessary to prevent burning.

      Meanwhile, put the kale and parsley into a food processor and p 20 to 25 times, until the size of almonds. Don’t overprocess. Transfer to a small bowl.

Finely chop the cranberries and add them to the bowl of greens.

      To the processor (no need to clean it out!), add the rolled oats. Process until they resemble coarse flour, about 30 seconds. Add the drained lentils and walnuts to the processor and pulse 13 times, until the walnuts are pea sized. Set aside.

 The Festive Bread-Free Stuffing Balls took lots of steps, dishes, etc., and 50 minutes rather than 30 to prepare. I made these while the potatoes were baking. 

      I’m not sure why these are called stuffing balls and not lentil nut balls or something because they didn’t have a stuffing-like consistency. They tasted all right, but were dense and a bit dry and definitely did need a sauce, which I didn’t make since I’d spent so much time on everything else with these two dishes. We later simmered them with some pasta sauce I had in the fridge; they held up nicely, and tasted much better.

Lots of nuts

      If you or anyone in your family has a nut allergy, this is not the book for you. A great many of the recipes use nuts or a sauce or condiment made from nuts. There is a lot of nutritional yeast in recipes as well, with a pronounced flavor.

Bounce around

      There are a lot of cross referencing to other recipes or sauces in the book, and with the two recipes I made I had to keep things bookmarked, and was frequently turning back and forth, sometimes with mucky hands. There’s a whole section of “Glow Getter Meal Plans” that have you thumbing back and forth with instructions like “Follow steps 3 (see tip below) through 5 and step 7” and you have to keep referencing back and forth to different recipes. I didn’t think any of this section was helpful.

Please give me a black typeface!

      The typeface, as with many these days, is colored grey rather than black and thus is harder to read! Why are they doing this? Additionally, one of my pet peeves with this book is the overuse of the “glow” references in just about everything. Sloppy Glows, Glow Getter Meal Plans, Glowing Lentil Soup, Glow Green Pasta, you get the idea. The first couple of references were silly, then just tiring.

The bottom line – to buy or not to buy

      The bottom line is, if you have never cooked vegan, don’t start with this book, you will be overwhelmed with the number of steps and sometimes convoluted instructions, with varying results. If you have cooked vegan for years, there are a lot of recipes that you might like to try, and some good sauces and condiments. But be prepared to spend more time than the recipe states, and to add what you know it is going to need. Like onions!

After spending years as a newspaper and radio reporter and magazine writer, I needed a change. So, my husband and I operated a small bed and breakfast inn in a big old Victorian in Southern Vermont for more years than I want to count, and as you can imagine, I have spent a lot of time in the kitchen, much of it looking for ways to save some of that time while still offering something memorable to my guests.

This also freed me to help produce local music concerts and festivals in our areas, including the popular Roots on the River Music Festival which finished it run in 2019. We have been blessed to have many wonderful singers and singer/songwriters stay at our humble inn, and a few who have performed here as well. Precious moments.

We were among the first Green Hotels in the state, and member of the Vermont Fresh Network. We are now open only for special events, cooking classes, and a little catering to keep things interesting. I write a food column, Memorable Meals, for our local newspaper, focusing on local foods and products from our fabulous southern Vermont farms, everything seasonal and delicious.

Thanks, Dot, for being a part of our food club and for sharing your knowledge with us.

I’m looking forward to hearing more of your thoughts and insights on future recipes and cookbooks. Your expertise and unique perspective are always welcome and appreciated.

15 responses to “COOKBOOK CONFIDENTIAL COOKBOOK CLUB – Dorothy Grover Read reviews Oh She Glows for Dinner”

  1. Awakening Wonders – Everyday life is filled with wondrous things and embraceable moments, but only if we allow ourselves to be fully awakened. I invite you to join me as I share passionate life adventures and ramblings that awaken my spirit. I look forward to awakening your senses to the simple, joyous wonders that are all around us. I feel that we are destined to become soulful adventurers!
    Awakening Wonders says:

    Appreciate the review of this cookbook. The Ultimate Creamy Salt-and-Vinegar Scalloped Potatoes looks like a recipe I may make in the future!

  2. Dorothy's New Vintage Kitchen – I'm a writer, cook, gardener, photographer, poet, quilter, and accomplished daydreamer. I'm also a wife, mother, grandmother, sister. cousin, aunt, and friend, no particular order on any given day. I've been a writer all my life, newspaper reporter and columnist, radio news writer, and magazine contributor, and poet and short-story writer as the spirit moves. Now, I turn my attention to my cookbook, the blog, and a cooking column "Memorable Meals," which runs in our county newspaper. Besides my family, I love dogs, cats, good coffee, chocolate, and my never-dwindling pile of books I intend to read. Our family ran a small Vermont Inn for 18 years, with our focus on local, organic ingredients. I cook from scratch, and try not to use anything that has ingredients I cannot pronounce! After many years of daily serving up local delicacies, cooking classes, and catering, we are now only open for special events, and the odd cooking class. We also host musicians and artists, having helped produce a musical festival and other musical events for nearly 20 years. Many incredible artists have found a place at our table. Wonderful experiences, we will treasure always. My family and friends are my practice subjects. With a family that includes nut, peanut, tree fruit, and vegetable allergies, gluten intolerance, dairy intolerance, vegetarians, vegans, heart conscious, and a couple of picky eaters, there has to be a few quick tricks in the book to keep everyone fed and happy! Personally, I do not eat red meat or most full-fat dairy (usually) for health reasons, making the occasional exception at Thanksgiving and Christmas or our anniversary if the duck is locally raised. I do eat fish and seafood, so I try to come up with alternatives and substitutions when available. I serve local organic eggs and cheeses to my family who can tolerate dairy (My husband recently had a heart attack, and I need to watch my own cholesterol so I am careful, but have been known to let a little piece of really good cheese accidentally fall on my plate!). I believe strongly that eating in a way that is good for our planet is also good for our bodies, and I try to educated myself about our food sources! I cook by the seasons and draw on inspiration from the strong and talented women in my family who came before me, as well as the youth in the family who look at the world with fresh eyes. Food links us all, whether sharing a meal, cooking it together, or writing about it for others to enjoy. I love taking an old recipe and giving it a modern spin, especially if I can make it a littler healthier and use foods that are kinder to the Earth and to our bodies. I believe strongly in sustainable, delicious eating of whole foods, and the wonderful flavors we have at our fingertips! And finally, I love conversing with all the talented cooks and chefs out there who dot the globe! It's a wonderful, world full of culinary pen pals, and I cherish them all! XXXOOO Dorothy
    Dorothy’s New Vintage Kitchen says:

    Thank you Bernadette! This project is lots of fun, and good discipline for me to actually make a recipe as printed and not immediately start messing with it! Tough for me to do!

  3. Hi Bernadette, Dorothy wrote a very detailed and thorough review of this book. Admittedly, these recipes ddid not appeal to me at all.

    • Interesting Robbie. I didn’t like all the cross referencing. This is what I like about my family of reviewers, everyone is different and has a different opinion and expresses it without getting snarky.

  4. Interesting…the cheesy titles got me as well.

  5. Retirement Reflections – Vancouver Island, BC – Prior to retirement, I lived and worked in Beijing China for fourteen years (Middle School Principal/Deputy Director at The Western Academy of Beijing). Leaving international life behind, my husband and I retired to Vancouver Island in June 2015. To document both this transition and our new adventures, ‘Retirement Reflections’ was born. I hope that you enjoy reading these reflections, and will be willing to share your own.
    Retirement Reflections says:

    Hi, Dorothy – Thank you so much for your candid review. If every book and every recipe was a hit with everyone, it would make the really great recipes less special. I have made the scalloped potatoes from this book and quite liked them. But I do agree about the frequent cross-referencing.

  6. while the cover offers lots of promise, it sounds like the cookbook fails to deliver

  7. Darlene – British Columbia, Canada – Writer of children's stories, short stories and travel articles.!/supermegawoman!/pages/Darlene-Foster-Writer/362236842733
    Darlene says:

    A great, honest review. I also no longer like recipes that are a lot of fuss and bother. At this stage of my life, simple is better. The meat balls in a sauce might be good though.

  8. the Painted Apron – Life is all about creativity for me, as long as I'm creating something I am happy! I hope I will inspire your daily life and give you ideas for your own wonderful creations!
    Jenna says:

    I always appreciate an honest review. I know Dorothy is a genius in the kitchen so I value what she says. I admire those who follow a plant based diet, but it is a lot of work.

    • You are right Jenna on both counts. Dot is a genius and it is A LOT of work living that plant based life. You can’t just throw something together.

Any comments or suggestions are appreciated. If you like this recipe, please give it to your friends.Cancel reply